The Two Pilot Reports Over Southern Arizona, 24 February 2018
Two crews who could not see each other reported the same thing within the hour, and the controller working them both had nothing on radar to offer.
What did witnesses see at Airway over southern Arizona?
On the afternoon of 24 February 2018, two aircraft flying east over southern Arizona reported the same object minutes apart. Neither crew could identify it, and the controller working them could not find anything that accounted for it.
The first report came from a Learjet 36 operated by Phoenix Air. Its pilot asked Albuquerque Air Route Traffic Control Center a question that reads, in the released recording, like a man checking whether he had imagined something: "Was anybody above us that passed us like 30 seconds ago?" The controller answered "Negative." The pilot replied, "OK. Something did."
About half an hour later the same controller put the question to the next aircraft on the same route, American Airlines Flight 1095, an Airbus A321. The controller's prompt is the part that matters, because it shows the sequence was not suggested by the airline crew: "we had an aircraft in front of you at 37 [thousand feet] that reported something pass over him." The American captain came back a short time afterwards with the line that became the story's headline: "Yeah, something just passed over us, like a, I don't know what it was. But it was at least two, three thousand feet above us."
Asked to describe it, he did something that is worth noting before anyone else characterises this case. He volunteered the mundane reading himself: "Couldn't make it out whether it was a balloon or whatnot. But it was just really beaming light or could have had a big reflection." The controller then asked whether it might have been a Google balloon, meaning one of the Project Loon high altitude internet balloons then being flown.
Both aircraft were at roughly 37,000 feet, tracking east, somewhere between the Sonoran Desert National Monument and the New Mexico border. The War Zone, which published the audio first, placed the two reports between about 3:30 and 4:15 in the afternoon local time. Arizona does not observe daylight saving, so those clock times are Mountain Standard, seven hours behind Universal Time.
There is no photograph, no video and no radar track. The entire evidentiary basis of this case is a few minutes of air traffic control audio that the Federal Aviation Administration released on request.
What is the official explanation?
There is no official identification of the object, and there is no investigation to report.
The FAA's position, as given to ABC News, is narrow and carefully worded. The controller "was unable to verify that any other aircraft was in the area at the time of the reported sightings." That is a statement about what the controller could see on his scope and in his flight strips. It is not a statement that nothing was there, and it should not be read as one.
An FAA spokesperson added the context that the agency safely handles military and civilian aircraft of all types in that airspace every day, "including high-altitude weather balloons." That sentence is the closest thing to an official candidate explanation anyone has offered, and it is an invitation to consider a balloon rather than a finding that this was one.
No incident report appears to have been filed by either crew, which is ordinary. A sighting that causes no loss of separation, no avoiding action and no damage generates no paperwork. The audio exists because the recording of the frequency exists, not because anybody opened a case.
It is worth being precise about what the release was. This is not a declassified file and it is not an AARO record. It is routine air traffic control audio, obtained and published by journalists, and it carries no agency assessment of any kind.
What did the witnesses think it was?
The two accounts are independent in the way that matters, and that is the strongest feature of the case.
The Learjet crew reported first, to a controller who had nothing to tell them. The American Airlines crew were then prompted by that controller, so their report is not strictly blind. But the prompt came from the controller rather than from the other pilot, the two aircraft were separated in time by roughly half an hour, and the second crew described the object in their own terms, including an estimate of its height above them that nobody had fed to them.
What neither crew offered is a shape. The American captain's description is of brightness, not structure: "really beaming light or could have had a big reflection." He could not tell whether it was a balloon. That is an honest report from a professional observer at 37,000 feet, and it constrains the case in a direction people often skip past, because a witness who cannot resolve an object cannot be cited as having seen a craft.
The second thing both crews agree on is position. It passed above them, by a margin the American captain put at two to three thousand feet, which places it near 40,000 feet. The Learjet pilot's phrasing, that something passed him about thirty seconds before he asked, implies relative motion rather than a stationary object, though at that closing geometry a slow object and a fast aircraft produce the same impression.
No crew member has since given a named public interview expanding the account, so what exists is what was said on frequency at the time. In evidentiary terms that is a strength rather than a weakness. These are contemporaneous statements made for an operational purpose, before anybody knew a reporter would ever hear them.
Is the Two Pilot Reports Over Southern Arizona, 24 February 2018 real? The two-pass assessment
Pass one, how could this be mundane. Comfortably, and the published skeptical case deserves to be stated properly rather than waved at.
The serious prosaic analysis is by James McGaha, a retired United States Air Force major and former special operations pilot who directs the Grasslands Observatory in Arizona and consults for the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry. Writing in Skeptical Inquirer for July and August 2018, he argued the object was very likely a balloon of some kind, most plausibly a high altitude research balloon. His reasoning rests on a general optical point: when a very bright light is seen in daylight, it is almost always sunlight reflecting off something, and a reflective, slowly drifting object high above an aircraft is exactly what that produces.
This archive ran the solar geometry independently, and it supports him. Computed for a point near Tucson with a routine validated against this archive's own published figures, the Sun at 15:30 Mountain Standard was at azimuth 233 and altitude 32 degrees, and by 16:15 it had moved to azimuth 241 and altitude 24 degrees. Both aircraft were tracking east, so through the whole window the Sun sat behind them in the southwest, between 24 and 32 degrees up. An object above and ahead of an eastbound aircraft in that geometry is front lit by a Sun the crew cannot see without turning round, which is the precise condition for a brilliant, structureless point of light. Two routes landing on the same answer is better than either alone, and the second route never used McGaha's numbers.
There is one qualification, and it cuts against the tidiest version of the balloon reading rather than for it. The reported height does not fit every balloon equally. A Project Loon balloon of the kind the controller named on the tape floats at roughly 58,000 to 70,000 feet, and a large scientific research balloon at float is usually above 100,000 feet. Both sit far above an object reported two to three thousand feet over a 37,000 foot aircraft. The balloon class that genuinely occupies 40,000 feet is a weather radiosonde, which passes through that band on every single flight while ascending. That is a narrower and more testable claim than "a balloon", and it is the one the FAA's own wording points toward.
This archive could not close that test. The National Weather Service launches radiosondes on a fixed schedule and the relevant sounding would show whether a balloon was aloft from Tucson in that window, but the University of Wyoming upper air archive, the usual route to historical soundings, has changed its URL structure: a control request for a recent date returned the same 404 as the 2018 one while the site root returned normally, so this is a route change and not an absence of data. The check is cheap for anyone who finds the current path, and it would materially sharpen the case in either direction.
Pass two, if it is not a balloon, what is it. The honest answer is that the material cannot carry a strong claim, and the reason is the same one that makes the case attractive. Audio is a good record of what people said and a poor record of what was in the sky. There is no angular size, no bearing, no track, no photograph and no radar return, so there is no way to derive a speed, a distance or a shape. Everything beyond "two crews saw something bright pass above them" is unconstrained.
What survives scrutiny is narrow and real: two professional crews on different aircraft, minutes apart, independently reported an unidentified bright object above a busy airway, and the controller responsible for that airspace could not account for it. The FAA has never identified it. A published, named, method shown analysis says balloon and is probably right, but it was not demonstrated, and the specific balloon the altitude actually fits is not the one the famous version of the story names.
The case is tiered Disputed on that basis. It is not Unknown, because a credible prosaic candidate exists and has been argued in print by a named analyst. It is not Strongly Disputed, because nobody has shown which object it was, and the altitude detail is an unresolved complication rather than a closed one.
Sources
- abcnews.com/US/pilots-report-close-encounters-ufo-arizona-passed-us/story?id=54067123
- www.twz.com/19095/listen-in-as-a-learjet-and-an-airbus-encounter-a-mystery-craft-high-over-arizona
- skepticalinquirer.org/2018/07/ufo-over-arizona-likely-an-ifo/
- time.com/5220209/pilots-ufo-arizona-plane/
- fortune.com/2018/03/29/american-airlines-pilots-ufo/
- www.livescience.com/62155-arizona-ufo-spotted-over-desert-2018.html
- api.adsbdb.com/v0/aircraft/N71PG
More cases from this region: UFO sightings in United States
