The Mercyhurst Triangle of Lights over Erie, Pennsylvania, 12 November 2026
Three white lights held a fixed triangular spacing over Erie for twenty eight seconds under a broken to overcast deck at 2,500 feet, which rules out every astronomical answer and promotes the one the witness ruled out.
What did witnesses see at Mercyhurst University?
At 11:23 PM on 12 November 2026 a visitor to Erie, Pennsylvania filmed a group of lights over Mercyhurst University. The recording runs 28.6 seconds and opens on a street light before the camera rises to the sky.
The lights are unambiguously real. Across the clip the three persistent sources peak at a median 89 sigma above the local background noise, with a tenth percentile of 49 sigma, so nothing here is compression noise or a sensor artifact.
What the footage actually resolves is three point sources and nothing else. In 544 of the 737 frames that carry the group, exactly three sources are present; in 177 frames only two are above threshold, which is one light dropping out rather than a light leaving. The group's maximum separation has a median of 13.0 pixels, and it does not change: the first quarter of the clip measures a median of 12.7 pixels and the last quarter 12.8 pixels, with a fitted trend of 0.21 pixels per second. The three lights therefore hold a constant mutual spacing for the whole recording, which means they are physically associated and are not appreciably changing range.
At that scale no hull, edge or surface is visible. The triangle in this case is the arrangement of three unresolved lights, not an observed structure, and the solid craft is an inference drawn from them.
What is the official explanation?
No official body has commented on this sighting. No aviation authority finding, police report or agency statement is associated with it, so the archive records the official narrative as absent.
What did the witnesses think it was?
The report was filed through the structured form at ufosighting.report and relayed to r/UFOs, with the submitter verified from their own Reddit account. The filing gives the time as 11:23 PM EST on 12 November 2026, the location as Mercyhurst Ice Center in Erie, the shape as a triangle, the distance as "as high as a plane", the apparent size as a quarter at arm's length, the movement as "straight and steady, random, smooth", and the observer facing north.
The witness's account is short and unembellished: "I was visiting a college friend when I looked up looking for satellites like I like to do when I saw a triangle like object over Mercyhurst University in Erie Pennsylvania."
Their single stated reason for rejecting a conventional aircraft is specific and testable: "Does not have the required blinking lights if it was a manmade aircraft to comply with FAA regulations."
The thread drew 136 comments, almost all of them other people's recollections of similar triangles going back to the 1990s rather than analysis of this clip. One commenter made a usable observation, reporting "the little lights blink off to the side of the triangle at 0:24".
Is the Mercyhurst Triangle of Lights over Erie, Pennsylvania, 12 November 2026 real? The two-pass assessment
Pass one, how could this be mundane. The sky itself does most of the work, and it does it in both directions.
Erie International Airport, about five kilometres from the sighting point, reported a broken deck at 3,600 feet at 22:51, a broken deck at 2,500 feet with an overcast layer at 3,600 feet at 23:38, and a broken deck at 2,600 feet with overcast at 3,100 feet at 23:51, with wind from 30 to 40 degrees at 12 to 16 knots and ten miles visibility throughout. The sighting at 23:23 falls inside that bracket.
The consequence is categorical. Under a broken to overcast deck at 2,500 to 3,600 feet, no star, planet or satellite is visible, so every astronomical explanation is not merely unlikely but impossible, and the filing's automated note that no bright satellites were overhead is irrelevant to a sky that was covered. Anything visible was beneath the cloud base, which also means it was low, and the witness's own estimate of "as high as a plane" is consistent with an object at approach altitude.
The same ceiling promotes the prosaic answer. Three white lights in a fixed triangular arrangement, seen from below at under 2,500 feet, five kilometres from a commercial airport, moving straight and steady, is the ordinary appearance of an aircraft on approach, where the triangle is formed by landing and wing lights rather than by a structure.
The witness's objection was tested and the test did not settle it. Faint transient sources do appear near the group in seventeen instances spread across the clip, including twice at 24.0 seconds, which is exactly where the commenter reported seeing lights blink. They are not, however, comparable to the three steady lights: their median peak is 9.6 sigma against 89.1 sigma for the persistent sources, a ratio of 0.11. A navigation strobe on the same airframe as three lights that bright would not register at a ninth of their amplitude. These detections are consistent with stars passing through the search radius, with compression artifacts, or with noise, and they are too faint to be called an anti-collision light. So the archive did not confirm a strobe, and it did not refute the witness either. The honest finding is that the question is open on this file.
Pass two, if this is not an aircraft, what is it. Three associated light sources holding a constant angular separation of about thirteen pixels for 28.6 seconds beneath a low cloud deck, with no resolvable structure and no confirmed anti-collision lighting. The strongest point in the witness's favour is their own: a conventional aircraft at that altitude and that proximity to an airport should carry a visible red strobe, and across 737 frames nothing of comparable brightness blinks.
Three limits belong on the record. The archive copy is 854 by 480 pixels and carries no camera creation timestamp, and the reporter stated plainly that the file was pulled from cloud storage and transferred to a PC before upload, so it cannot be dated or authenticated from its metadata and the oldest traceable appearance is the filing. At thirteen pixels of separation the resolution available cannot support any claim about shape, size or solidity. And the sighting's own hour cannot be checked against air traffic from here, because historical ADS-B playback for 23:23 Eastern over Erie requires an interactive browser session.
The case is tiered Disputed. The aircraft candidate is strongly promoted by the cloud deck, the low altitude it forces and the proximity of Erie International, and nothing in the material demonstrates it, while the absence of a confirmed strobe remains unexplained. The test that would close it is historical ADS-B playback for that minute.
Sources
- www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/1xvpxgu/triangle_object_moved_straight_and_steady_over/
- ufosighting.report/sighting/13270/triangle-object-moved-straight-and-steady-over-mercyhurst-ic
- mesonet.agron.iastate.edu/cgi-bin/request/asos.py?station=ERI&data=drct&data=sknt&data=skyc1&data=skyl1&data=skyc2&data=skyl2&data=vsby&year1=2026&month1=11&day1=12&year2=2026&month2=11&day2=13&tz=America%2FNew_York&format=onlycomma&report_type=3&report_type=4
- geocoding.geo.census.gov/geocoder/locations/onelineaddress?address=501+E+38th+St%2C+Erie%2C+PA+16546&benchmark=Public_AR_Current&format=json
More cases from this region: UFO sightings in United States
